Egg Donation: A Victory for Reproductive Justice or Another Handmaid’s Tale?
By Chantal Bittner,
Bill of Health
| 02. 04. 2025
Before the United States election in 2024, Margaret Atwood shared a cartoon illustrating the handmaids from her dystopian novel entering a polling booth in their unmistakable red cloaks and white bonnets. Having voted, they transform into unique individuals, discarding the attire symbolizing their reproductive enslavement.
One of the central topics of the election campaign was undoubtedly abortion—a key issue in the fight for reproductive justice. However, reproductive justice encompasses far more than abortion. The egg donation industry has expanded into a multi-billion dollar market. While altruism frequently frames their actions, financial incentives are central to attracting many young women to donate—really, sell—their eggs. Upon closer examination, egg donors play a subordinate role despite being essential for the market to function. This post explores the egg market in the U.S. and Europe, shedding light on its implications for the reproductive rights of third parties involved in the process.
The U.S.: A free market model
In the U.S., egg donation operates as an unregulated free market. Compensation varies widely, reaching up to $250,000 in exceptional cases, with an average payment of approximately $7,000. Efforts by the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) to regulate this market through guidelines capping payments failed: ASRM attempted to limit donor remuneration to $10,000. However, two donors sued ASRM, claiming the guidelines violated U.S. antitrust laws by constituting price-fixing. In 2015...
Related Articles
By Anna Louie Sussman, The New York Times | 04.08.2025
Before fertility patients begin the long journey through hormone treatments, egg retrieval, fertilization and — hopefully, if everything goes well — a baby, there’s the paperwork. As a first order of business, would-be parents are typically presented with a form...
By Berkeley Lovelace Jr. and Abigail Brooks, NBC News | 04.02.2025
By Anna Louie Sussman, The New York Times | 04.01.2025
When Noor Siddiqui was growing up, her mother developed retinitis pigmentosa, a condition that leads to gradual vision loss. When Ms. Siddiqui’s mother was in her 30s, she began going blind. Last summer, Ms. Siddiqui told a podcast host that...
By Anna Louie Sussman, The New York Times | 03.25.2025
On June 24, 2022, the same day the Supreme Court issued its decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, I received a call from the fertility clinic where I’d been undergoing in vitro fertilization, informing me that seven of...