Here We Go Again: Why is the FDA Reifying Race as Genetic?
By Jonathan Kahn, Biopolitical Times guest contributor
| 03. 17. 2011
In recent years the issue of whether, how and when to use racial categories in biomedicine has been a subject of heated and extended debates that have ranged over wide areas of research and practice. Over the past decade, significant scientific advances sparked by the federally financed Human Genome Project have placed genetics at the center of many of these debates. In no area is this more pronounced than in the field of pharmacogenomics, the study of how individual genetic differences affect drug response.
Ostensibly, pharmacogenomics is all about the individual, not about race. Indeed, part of its promise is its purported ability to move beyond race, to render it irrelevant as a biological category in assessing drugs response. Yet pharmacogenomics remains in its infancy. Some progress has been made, but a
recent report from the Royal Society in the United Kingdom asserts that realizing the promise of truly individualized pharmacogenomic therapies remains decades away. Nonetheless, major government, academia, and industry initiatives are drawing huge amounts of material and intellectual capital into the pursuit of this distant promise.
I am...
Related Articles
Flag of South Africa; design by Frederick Brownell,
image by WikimediaCommons users.
Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
What is the legal status of heritable human genome editing (HHGE)? In 2020, a comprehensive policy analysis by Baylis, Darnovsky, Hasson, and Krahn documented that more than 70 countries and an international treaty prohibit it, and that no country explicitly permits it. Policies in some countries were non-existent, ambiguous, or subject to possible amendment, but the general rule remained, even after one...
By Bernice Lottering, Gene Online | 11.08.2024
South Africa’s updated health-research ethics guidelines, which now include heritable human genome editing, have sparked concern among scientists. The revisions, made in May but only recently gaining attention, outline protocols for modifying genetic material in sperm, eggs, or embryos—changes that...
By Jim Thomas, Scan the Horizon | 11.19.2024
It’s the wee hours of 2nd November 2024 in Cali, Colombia. In a large UN negotiating hall Colombian Environment Minister Susana Muhamed has slammed down the gavel on a decision that should send a jolt through the AI policy world. ...
By Ned Pagliarulo, BioPharmaDive | 11.05.2024
A medicine built around a more precise form of CRISPR gene editing appeared to work as designed in its first clinical trial test, developer Beam Therapeutics said Tuesday. But the death of a trial participant could renew concerns about an older...