Cell Free DNA Screening is not a Simple Blood Test
By SMFM,
Society for Maternal Fetal Medicine
| 12. 18. 2014
A recent article in the Boston Globe presents a disturbing picture of prenatal testing, in a report describing how “Oversold prenatal tests spur some to choose abortions.” The article goes on to discuss prenatal screening with cell free DNA, and to present a number of patient cases in which the screening test indicated that a patient was at high risk for aneuploidy when in fact, the fetus was normal.
It is important for providers to remember that cell free DNA is a screening test, and does not have the diagnostic accuracy of amniocentesis. By its very nature, a screening test does not tell with 100% certainty whether or not a fetus will be affected by a given disorder. Unfortunately, in part because of the high stakes in this very competitive market, the tests are being presented as having >99% accuracy, the same accuracy as is used to describe amniocentesis and CVS.
While the detection rates for trisomy 21 are very high, and the false positive rate is very low, the test is less accurate and effective for detection...
Related Articles
By Nick Paul Taylor, BioSpace | 03.14.2024
A U.K. watchdog balked at the cost-effectiveness of Vertex Pharmaceuticals’ CRISPR-based sickle cell disease therapy Thursday, recommending against funding the treatment unless uncertainties can be cleared up satisfactorily.
The U.K. became the first country to authorize Vertex’s Casgevy (exagamglogene...
By Daniel Gilbert, The Washington Post | 03.07.2024
Vitaly Kushnir’s fertility clinic offers to screen an embryo to predict a baby’s sex, but the service can lead to ethically murky territory, like when a couple wanted it so their first child could be a boy.
But the couple...
By MANUEL ANSEDE, El País | 03.01.2024
A team of Italian researchers has reached a major scientific milestone, heralding a revolution in the field of medicine. The scientists have succeeded in silencing a gene associated with high cholesterol levels, without the need to modify DNA. In the...
By Anne Rumberger and Marcy Darnovsky, Science for the People | 02.29.2024
Eugenics is widely regarded as a debunked pseudoscience—developed and promoted mostly in Nazi Germany—that fell off the political radar after the horrors of the Holocaust were revealed. In fact, twentieth century eugenics represented the mainstream science of its day and...